The definition of Dishonestly in BNS is crucial for understanding criminal liability in property and financial offences. Defined in Section 2(7), it focuses on the intent to cause wrongful gain or loss. This article delves into its definition, comparison with the IPC, and practical significance in offences like theft and cheating, highlighting the principles of fairness and justice in the Indian legal system.
definition of Dishonestly in BNS
The BNS defines “dishonestly” in Section 2(7) as:
“dishonestly” means doing anything with the intention of causing wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person
This definition centers on the intent behind an action, specifically the intent to cause either “wrongful gain” or “wrongful loss”.
To further understand this definition, we need to examine the related concepts of “wrongful gain” and “wrongful loss,” as defined in the BNS:
- Section 2(37): “wrongful loss” means the loss by unlawful means of property to which the person losing it is legally entitled.
- Section 2(38): “gaining wrongfully” means a person retains wrongfully, as well as when a person acquires wrongfully. A person is said to lose wrongfully when such person is wrongfully kept out of any property, as well as when such person is wrongfully deprived of property.
Therefore, to act “dishonestly” under the BNS involves:
- Performing an action: This could encompass a wide range of actions, including physical acts, verbal statements, or even omissions.
- With the intention to cause: The definition emphasizes that the action must be carried out with a specific intent. It’s not enough for the action to merely result in wrongful gain or loss; the individual must have acted with the purpose of bringing about that outcome.
- Either wrongful gain or wrongful loss: The definition provides two alternative scenarios:
- Wrongful gain: This involves a person unlawfully acquiring or retaining property that they are not entitled to.
- Wrongful loss: This occurs when a person is unlawfully deprived of property to which they have a legal right, or when they are unjustly prevented from accessing or enjoying their property.
Simplifying the Definition:
The BNS definition of “dishonestly” can be summarized as:
Intentionally acting to cause someone to gain or lose property unlawfully.
Comparison with IPC:
The BNS definition of “dishonestly” differs slightly from the wording in Section 24 of the IPC. The IPC states:
Whoever does anything with the intention of causing wrongful gain to one person or wrongful loss to another person, is said to do that thing “dishonestly”.
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) definition removes the phrase “is said to do that thing dishonestly,” making the definition more direct and concise while retaining the core concept.
Applications and Insights:
The concept of “dishonesty” plays a crucial role throughout the BNS, particularly in defining various offences related to property and financial dealings. Some examples include:
- Theft (Section 226): The definition of theft explicitly requires the taking of property “dishonestly.” This means the individual must have intended to cause wrongful gain to themselves or wrongful loss to the owner of the property.
- Criminal breach of trust (Section 316): This offence involves a person entrusted with property misusing it “dishonestly.” This highlights that even if someone lawfully possesses property, their actions can become criminal if they intend to cause wrongful gain or loss through their misuse of that property.
- Cheating (Section 318): Cheating involves deceiving someone to induce them to do or omit something that causes or is likely to cause damage. This deception must be carried out “fraudulently or dishonestly.” This implies that the individual must have intended to cause wrongful gain to themselves or wrongful loss to the person they are deceiving.
Importance of Understanding “Dishonestly” in the BNS:
The definition of “dishonestly” is a cornerstone of many offences in the BNS. It helps distinguish between acts that are merely negligent or careless and those that involve a deliberate intention to cause unlawful gain or loss. This distinction is crucial for determining criminal liability and ensuring that the law appropriately addresses different levels of culpability.
By understanding how the BNS defines “dishonestly,” one can better comprehend the scope and application of various criminal offences, gain insights into the legal implications of their actions, and appreciate the underlying principles of fairness and justice embedded in the legal framework.
READ MORE: What is the definition of Good Faith in BNS?
How does BNS redefine “child” and “Judge”?
What are the changes made to the definition of “offence” in the BNS?
